What do you think?
Rate this book
Celestial Persuasion
Abigail Isaacs fears ever again falling under the power of love and dedicates her life to studying the heavens. However, upon her father’s demise she finds herself in reduced circumstances and must write to her brother, who has long been away at sea. When instead Captain Wentworth of the HMS Laconia sends a tragic reply, Abigail is asked to set aside her own ambitions and fulfill her brother’s dreams in the Viceroyalty of Río de la Plata.
In his relentless pursuit for justice, Lieutenant Raphael Gabay lends his sword to the Spanish American cause. But as he prepares to set sail with the others, he is entrusted with the care of a young woman. She is quite unlike anyone he has ever known, and Raphael begins to wonder whether the brilliant astronomer will see beyond his frivolous façade and recognize his true nature.
Their destinies have been plotted beyond the celestial veil; their charts foretell of adventure. Can these two troubled souls be persuaded to heed the stars and find love—and their purpose—in this fledgling nation?
In his relentless pursuit for justice, Lieutenant Raphael Gabay lends his sword to the Spanish American cause. But as he prepares to set sail with the others, he is entrusted with the care of a young woman. She is quite unlike anyone he has ever known, and Raphael begins to wonder whether the brilliant astronomer will see beyond his frivolous façade and recognize his true nature.
Their destinies have been plotted beyond the celestial veil; their charts foretell of adventure. Can these two troubled souls be persuaded to heed the stars and find love—and their purpose—in this fledgling nation?
302 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 30, 2021
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews
June 18, 2021
This is such a brilliant combination of historical and women's fiction, as well as a tribute to Jane Austen's Persuasion It begins in England in the Regency era and travels to Buenos Aires, in the beginnings of a fight for the South American colonies' independence from Spain.
Brilliant, but unable to go to college because she is a woman, Abigail Isaacs has few choices other than to study astronomy in her comfortable English home. However, upon the death of her father, Abigail writes to her brother Jonathan, who is serving on a ship called The Argo. Unfortunately she is told by none other than Austen character Captain Wentworth that her brother, a friend of Wentworth's, has just passed away under violent circumstances because he was Jewish. Abigail is surprised to find out that her late father and brother had invested in property in South America, and that they were part of a secret society that wants to free Buenos Aires from Spanish rule. She eventually decides to travel to Buenos Aires on the frigate George Canning, along with her loyal companion, Mrs. Frankel. They are also accompanied by her brother's associates, José Francisco de San Martín and Raphael Gabay de Montoya. They are part of a Freemason-affiliated secret society interested in freeing Buenos Aires from Spanish rule.
I was immediately transported to the Regency era in Britain, and then to South America at the time of Spanish rule. The characters all came to life and the places were described in such vivid detail that I felt as if I were there. The descriptions of the ship voyage were especially real and fascinating. The customs, rules, and prejudices of the era were described in sometimes painful detail, especially the racism against Jews, which was evident in circumstances that occurred early in the book. Jewish traditions, terms, and customs are explained throughout this captivating novel.
The bow to Jane Austen comes not only in the inclusion of Wentworth, but also in the language and tone of the book. There is also a surprise in the book that nobody will see coming.
I was blown away by the author's remarkable ability to write a prequel to Persuasion , add in Jewish traditions and history, expertly combine historical, literary, and fictional characters, and eloquently surround it all with the South American independence movement. I would highly recommend this to fans of Jewish and South American historical fiction, as well as to readers who love strong female characters.
I received a free copy of this book from the author. My review is voluntary and my opinions are my own.
Brilliant, but unable to go to college because she is a woman, Abigail Isaacs has few choices other than to study astronomy in her comfortable English home. However, upon the death of her father, Abigail writes to her brother Jonathan, who is serving on a ship called The Argo. Unfortunately she is told by none other than Austen character Captain Wentworth that her brother, a friend of Wentworth's, has just passed away under violent circumstances because he was Jewish. Abigail is surprised to find out that her late father and brother had invested in property in South America, and that they were part of a secret society that wants to free Buenos Aires from Spanish rule. She eventually decides to travel to Buenos Aires on the frigate George Canning, along with her loyal companion, Mrs. Frankel. They are also accompanied by her brother's associates, José Francisco de San Martín and Raphael Gabay de Montoya. They are part of a Freemason-affiliated secret society interested in freeing Buenos Aires from Spanish rule.
I was immediately transported to the Regency era in Britain, and then to South America at the time of Spanish rule. The characters all came to life and the places were described in such vivid detail that I felt as if I were there. The descriptions of the ship voyage were especially real and fascinating. The customs, rules, and prejudices of the era were described in sometimes painful detail, especially the racism against Jews, which was evident in circumstances that occurred early in the book. Jewish traditions, terms, and customs are explained throughout this captivating novel.
The bow to Jane Austen comes not only in the inclusion of Wentworth, but also in the language and tone of the book. There is also a surprise in the book that nobody will see coming.
I was blown away by the author's remarkable ability to write a prequel to Persuasion , add in Jewish traditions and history, expertly combine historical, literary, and fictional characters, and eloquently surround it all with the South American independence movement. I would highly recommend this to fans of Jewish and South American historical fiction, as well as to readers who love strong female characters.
I received a free copy of this book from the author. My review is voluntary and my opinions are my own.
May 22, 2021
Jane Austen's influence is apparent throughout this lovely Regency story about a twenty-seven-year-old Jewish woman, Abigail Isaacs. Having received a bluestocking-type education from her father, a doctor, Abigail has been content to continue studying astrology in her rural English village. Sadly, Dr. Isaacs dies, followed soon after by news of the death of Abigail's brother, Jonathan, a naval doctor who served for years under his good friend, Captain Wentworth. The captain's letter urges Abigail to come to London and meet with Lord Fife, which was Jonathan's fervent request upon his deathbed.
Lord Fife presents Abigail with startling information regarding plans her father and brother had made without her knowledge. She finds herself at a crossroads - she can stay in England, where there are few opportunities for an impoverished single woman, or she can board a ship and sail to Argentina for the future her family members had intended for her.
Abigail makes the difficult decision to pull up roots, leave her synagogue and lifelong friends, and follow the stars to the unknown. She's accompanied by her loyal companion, Mrs. Frankel, and makes many new acquaintances along the way to her final destination.
There are so many wonderful elements interwoven into this story, I hardly know where to start. The first pages describe a shocking example of anti-Jewish bigotry, which is subsequently a strong thread throughout the book and generally is presented in a stoic, matter-of-fact manner. The few options available to Regency era women, regardless of their intelligence and capability, is another theme. Readers of historical literature are certainly accustomed to British history; this story does begin in Exeter and London but soon moves on. Abigail and Mrs. Frankel spend weeks aboard an ocean frigate, experiencing the wonders and perils of sea travel during the Napoleonic war. They land in Buenos Aires to find an entirely different culture than they're accustomed to. Argentina is a new land that's a melting pot of various ethnicities and indigenous groups. There's a fight for the country's independence going on, which also affects the story. Things move on to Rosario, Argentina, bringing another change of scenery and culture.
But this book is much more than a historical travelogue. From a literary perspective, I love the way Jane Austen's characters are sewn into the book. Abigail and Captain Wentworth continue to correspond, and the evidence of this being a prequel to Persuasion becomes obvious. The plot itself shows some faint parallels to Persuasion as well.
Abigail is a strong, believable lead character. Her journey covers miles and miles, both the physical kind and the self-discovery kind. She's passionate about her study of the stars, which sometimes gets her in trouble, and she's determined to fulfill the mission her brother set out for her even though she doesn't feel qualified to handle it. With so much to do, she won't allow herself to fall in love, but love finds her anyway. It's not a romance that sizzles, but the connection between her and Raphael Gabay is developed convincingly. All the supporting characters (both imagined and actual historical figures) have interesting, three-dimensional personalities.
While Abigail's Jewishness is certainly a central focus, I must commend the respect offered to several other faiths throughout the story, emphasizing that which we have in common rather than that which separates us.
I loved this book!
I received an ARC from the author with no promise of a review, favorable or otherwise.
Lord Fife presents Abigail with startling information regarding plans her father and brother had made without her knowledge. She finds herself at a crossroads - she can stay in England, where there are few opportunities for an impoverished single woman, or she can board a ship and sail to Argentina for the future her family members had intended for her.
Abigail makes the difficult decision to pull up roots, leave her synagogue and lifelong friends, and follow the stars to the unknown. She's accompanied by her loyal companion, Mrs. Frankel, and makes many new acquaintances along the way to her final destination.
There are so many wonderful elements interwoven into this story, I hardly know where to start. The first pages describe a shocking example of anti-Jewish bigotry, which is subsequently a strong thread throughout the book and generally is presented in a stoic, matter-of-fact manner. The few options available to Regency era women, regardless of their intelligence and capability, is another theme. Readers of historical literature are certainly accustomed to British history; this story does begin in Exeter and London but soon moves on. Abigail and Mrs. Frankel spend weeks aboard an ocean frigate, experiencing the wonders and perils of sea travel during the Napoleonic war. They land in Buenos Aires to find an entirely different culture than they're accustomed to. Argentina is a new land that's a melting pot of various ethnicities and indigenous groups. There's a fight for the country's independence going on, which also affects the story. Things move on to Rosario, Argentina, bringing another change of scenery and culture.
But this book is much more than a historical travelogue. From a literary perspective, I love the way Jane Austen's characters are sewn into the book. Abigail and Captain Wentworth continue to correspond, and the evidence of this being a prequel to Persuasion becomes obvious. The plot itself shows some faint parallels to Persuasion as well.
Abigail is a strong, believable lead character. Her journey covers miles and miles, both the physical kind and the self-discovery kind. She's passionate about her study of the stars, which sometimes gets her in trouble, and she's determined to fulfill the mission her brother set out for her even though she doesn't feel qualified to handle it. With so much to do, she won't allow herself to fall in love, but love finds her anyway. It's not a romance that sizzles, but the connection between her and Raphael Gabay is developed convincingly. All the supporting characters (both imagined and actual historical figures) have interesting, three-dimensional personalities.
While Abigail's Jewishness is certainly a central focus, I must commend the respect offered to several other faiths throughout the story, emphasizing that which we have in common rather than that which separates us.
I loved this book!
I received an ARC from the author with no promise of a review, favorable or otherwise.
January 25, 2024
Beautiful Jewish representation!!
Oh how wonderful it was to find a book written about a Jewish Protagonist that actually kept to her faith, unlike most secular Jewish representation in literature today. I loved all the Jane Austen ties as well. A great book for Jane Austen lovers, even if you haven't yet read Persuasion, like me. I did look up a quick synopsis of Persuasion before I started, so I had a general idea of the story, so I wasn't lost when reading the letters to and from Captain Wentworth and Abigail Isaacs. Again, absolutely loved this book, for the writing as well as FINALLY finding an #OwnVoices book that I could relate to!!!
Oh how wonderful it was to find a book written about a Jewish Protagonist that actually kept to her faith, unlike most secular Jewish representation in literature today. I loved all the Jane Austen ties as well. A great book for Jane Austen lovers, even if you haven't yet read Persuasion, like me. I did look up a quick synopsis of Persuasion before I started, so I had a general idea of the story, so I wasn't lost when reading the letters to and from Captain Wentworth and Abigail Isaacs. Again, absolutely loved this book, for the writing as well as FINALLY finding an #OwnVoices book that I could relate to!!!
April 30, 2023
Mirta Ines Trupp was one of the first people I met on Goodreads. Or was it even Shelfari? Pretty quickly I joined the Jewish Book Club, and that is a great place to meet new rising authors of Jewish fiction, non-fiction, historical fiction. We are Goodreads friends, and let me tell you, she seems a really neat lady. I have now read three of her four novels, beginning with Becoming Malka. She is of Latina descent, and her books merge and blend some very unique interests. For one, Mirta is a huge fan of Jane Austen. Who would have ever conceived to blend Jewish historical fiction with Jane Austen? For two, she writes often of Argentina and Spain and South America, and has her characters reflect that aspect of Jewish Diaspora history. For three, she has an interest in geneology, astronomy, and astrology, and that is where this relatively unknown book gets its title - Celestial Persuasion. Because it is meant to pack all of those themes in there, and it does. It's unique.
Mirta conceptualizes and envisions this book as a pre-cursor to Persuasion. Many of Persuasions' characters (as well as historical Jewish figures) dominate the book, and Abigail Issacs is meant to fit right in. A Jewish young girl taking part in English society. I think I would have gotten more out of it, had I read Persuasion and red it recently. But what I so appreciate is Mirta's efforts to do something so unique. Abigail Issacs is also a young astronomer, astrologer, and mathematician. And she sails to uncover a mystery (and destiny) related to the loss of her brother. Like her other heroines, Abigail is feisty, determined, and not quite "of her time."
I want to say something of Jewish Astrology, which is an extremely unknown topic. I learned something of it as a young girl, and I find this fascinating. I have long said that the Judeo Christian Faith descends from early Wicca - the idea that there is a force that connects us all to each other, and to plants and animals in the world as that well. You could name that force God or Collective Unconscious, Source, what have you. And there is an idea that that source can be tapped into. For knowledge, or manipulation, what have you. There are 22 letters in the Hebrew Alphabet - these correspond to the 22 themes of the Major Arcana in the Tarot. There are four suits in a deck of cards, these relate to Air, Earth, Fire, and Water, as does the Four Suits of the Tarot. Jewish learning has incorporated these four worlds in all kinds of enumerable ways, one being the way we look at our torah portions and understand them on four levels. But Jewish Astrology is a whole 'nother subset. Let me explain.
Jacob has 12 sons and a daughter. These twelve sons represent the 12 tribes of Israel, for whom have created our current diaspora all over the world. So if you are thinking each of the brothers represents a month in the Lunar calendar, a different set of traits and characteristics, you got it. This is Jewish Astrology. Your Hebrew/Lunar Month represents a "brother". I think mine is Dan. I was born on December 28th, 1968. But a 2000 year calendar converter will show that on that day, it was the 7th of Tevet, the month that follows Kislev. Kislev is the "December" month, and Chanukah, which naturally jumps around, is always right on time. It begins on the 25th of Kislev. Think Christmas. The 25th word in the opening paragraph of the Torah is Or. Light. Let There Be Light. When it came time to pick a day for the Christmas story, this is how they came up with December 25th, even though Jesus was born in summer. Anyway, Chanukah ends on the 2nd of Tevet, (January-ish), and I am born five days later. Which is good, because I always know when my Hebrew birthday is. I can always count due to the closeness of the holiday. Why is it important to know when your Hebrew birthday is Because its a direct line to God on that day, and you can make specific prayers and intentions for yourself and others. Which I do, every year. Take advantage of that connection and direct energetic line. But back to Jewish Astrology. There are 12 stones on our Torah plates, the decorative plaque that hangs on our Torah Scrolls atop the Torah Cover. Each of these differing gems, relate to the brothers, the months, the constellations. The position of the planets. That is Jewish Astrology. The Dan's are the Capricorns. Related to Devorah (my mother's hebrew name) Judge. Which unfortunately fits and tracks her, despite that she is a Sagitarius. In any case, very few people know that the Jewish tradition seems to have its own derivation of astrology that matches and is precursor to the current design. Precursor to Persuasion, Precursor to our current Astrological Understanding. That is Mirta Ines Trupp. With a Jewish historical fiction and Latina twist. She has such a nice smile too. Anyway, I enjoyed the book, the underpinnings and allusions and references even more. Brava Mirta. Yasher Koach! For an interesting never before seen or envisioned take and intertwine.
Mirta conceptualizes and envisions this book as a pre-cursor to Persuasion. Many of Persuasions' characters (as well as historical Jewish figures) dominate the book, and Abigail Issacs is meant to fit right in. A Jewish young girl taking part in English society. I think I would have gotten more out of it, had I read Persuasion and red it recently. But what I so appreciate is Mirta's efforts to do something so unique. Abigail Issacs is also a young astronomer, astrologer, and mathematician. And she sails to uncover a mystery (and destiny) related to the loss of her brother. Like her other heroines, Abigail is feisty, determined, and not quite "of her time."
I want to say something of Jewish Astrology, which is an extremely unknown topic. I learned something of it as a young girl, and I find this fascinating. I have long said that the Judeo Christian Faith descends from early Wicca - the idea that there is a force that connects us all to each other, and to plants and animals in the world as that well. You could name that force God or Collective Unconscious, Source, what have you. And there is an idea that that source can be tapped into. For knowledge, or manipulation, what have you. There are 22 letters in the Hebrew Alphabet - these correspond to the 22 themes of the Major Arcana in the Tarot. There are four suits in a deck of cards, these relate to Air, Earth, Fire, and Water, as does the Four Suits of the Tarot. Jewish learning has incorporated these four worlds in all kinds of enumerable ways, one being the way we look at our torah portions and understand them on four levels. But Jewish Astrology is a whole 'nother subset. Let me explain.
Jacob has 12 sons and a daughter. These twelve sons represent the 12 tribes of Israel, for whom have created our current diaspora all over the world. So if you are thinking each of the brothers represents a month in the Lunar calendar, a different set of traits and characteristics, you got it. This is Jewish Astrology. Your Hebrew/Lunar Month represents a "brother". I think mine is Dan. I was born on December 28th, 1968. But a 2000 year calendar converter will show that on that day, it was the 7th of Tevet, the month that follows Kislev. Kislev is the "December" month, and Chanukah, which naturally jumps around, is always right on time. It begins on the 25th of Kislev. Think Christmas. The 25th word in the opening paragraph of the Torah is Or. Light. Let There Be Light. When it came time to pick a day for the Christmas story, this is how they came up with December 25th, even though Jesus was born in summer. Anyway, Chanukah ends on the 2nd of Tevet, (January-ish), and I am born five days later. Which is good, because I always know when my Hebrew birthday is. I can always count due to the closeness of the holiday. Why is it important to know when your Hebrew birthday is Because its a direct line to God on that day, and you can make specific prayers and intentions for yourself and others. Which I do, every year. Take advantage of that connection and direct energetic line. But back to Jewish Astrology. There are 12 stones on our Torah plates, the decorative plaque that hangs on our Torah Scrolls atop the Torah Cover. Each of these differing gems, relate to the brothers, the months, the constellations. The position of the planets. That is Jewish Astrology. The Dan's are the Capricorns. Related to Devorah (my mother's hebrew name) Judge. Which unfortunately fits and tracks her, despite that she is a Sagitarius. In any case, very few people know that the Jewish tradition seems to have its own derivation of astrology that matches and is precursor to the current design. Precursor to Persuasion, Precursor to our current Astrological Understanding. That is Mirta Ines Trupp. With a Jewish historical fiction and Latina twist. She has such a nice smile too. Anyway, I enjoyed the book, the underpinnings and allusions and references even more. Brava Mirta. Yasher Koach! For an interesting never before seen or envisioned take and intertwine.
June 13, 2022
"There now," said Abigail. "If you must indulge your romantic sensibilities pray turn your attention to that young couple. Judging by the reaction of the general assembly, theirs will be the stuff worthy of one of your novels."
Oh my! I was not able to put this book down.
Summary:
Abigail is in a dire situation; her father has passed away, and she is writing to her brother, who is away at sea, to return. She is pushed into an even worse situation when her letter is replied to by Captain Wentworth, informing her of the other tragic news. She is advised by the Captain to travel to London and meet Lord Fife, who was with her brother in the difficult times. Upon meeting Lord Fife, she is asked by him to fulfill his brother's dream by traveling to Buenos Aires and joining the revolution. Abigail had never left her small village, and even travelling to London was a first for her. She knows she has led a sheltered life, always shadowing her brother or her father. She has a huge decision to make. Whether to marry someone from her village and lead a comfortable life surrounded by people she knows, or to accept the adventure and face the unknown by travelling to Buenos Aires and fulfilling her brother's dream.
Lieutenant Raphael Gabay has been entrusted with her safety from London to Buenos Aires. The thing that both didn't count on was getting on each other's nerves.
Plot: This book is a prequel to Jane Austen's Persuasion, but even if you haven't read Persuasion, you'll enjoy it. I myself have not read Persuasion, but I enjoyed this one, and I am convinced to read Persuasion soon. Hence, maintaining my reading order.
Focusing on the Jewish community, the culture, their struggles in the 19th century, and Argentina's freedom, the plot is filled with intriguing information. The amount of research put into this book by the author is amazing. I loved learning about Jewish culture and was amazed at how much I didn't know. Not only this, the historical events depicted in the book allowed us readers to educate ourselves on the struggle for freedom in the region.
Characters: I loved Abigail. Her inner transformation from a dependent and naïve character to a decided, independent, powerful, and ambitious character is fascinating to watch. We rarely see non-extroverts as main characters, and I loved the fact that she remained true to herself. Growing stronger throughout the book didn't mean that she had to transform and become the opposite of who she was.
Frankly, I have developed a little crush on Mr. Gabay and cannot help mooning over him in my head. His acceptance of Abigail's headstrong character and her love for astronomy, which were uncommon traits for a woman in that century, was wonderfully depicted.
Romance: The romance here is to die for. Spanning almost a year, Abigail and Mr. Gabay's romance is heartwarming and passionate.
Writing: The author Mirta Ines Trupp did a fantastic job transferring us to the nineteenth century and bringing us alongside Abigail as she experienced the revolution in Argentina. Because the book touches on astronomy, Jewish culture, and the revolution, the readers are presented with numerous accurate facts that are expertly weaved into the plot.
Recommendation: Sprinkled with a few well-placed twists, this book is a wonderful gift for readers looking for historical fiction with a classic romance.
Oh my! I was not able to put this book down.
Summary:
Abigail is in a dire situation; her father has passed away, and she is writing to her brother, who is away at sea, to return. She is pushed into an even worse situation when her letter is replied to by Captain Wentworth, informing her of the other tragic news. She is advised by the Captain to travel to London and meet Lord Fife, who was with her brother in the difficult times. Upon meeting Lord Fife, she is asked by him to fulfill his brother's dream by traveling to Buenos Aires and joining the revolution. Abigail had never left her small village, and even travelling to London was a first for her. She knows she has led a sheltered life, always shadowing her brother or her father. She has a huge decision to make. Whether to marry someone from her village and lead a comfortable life surrounded by people she knows, or to accept the adventure and face the unknown by travelling to Buenos Aires and fulfilling her brother's dream.
Lieutenant Raphael Gabay has been entrusted with her safety from London to Buenos Aires. The thing that both didn't count on was getting on each other's nerves.
Plot: This book is a prequel to Jane Austen's Persuasion, but even if you haven't read Persuasion, you'll enjoy it. I myself have not read Persuasion, but I enjoyed this one, and I am convinced to read Persuasion soon. Hence, maintaining my reading order.
Focusing on the Jewish community, the culture, their struggles in the 19th century, and Argentina's freedom, the plot is filled with intriguing information. The amount of research put into this book by the author is amazing. I loved learning about Jewish culture and was amazed at how much I didn't know. Not only this, the historical events depicted in the book allowed us readers to educate ourselves on the struggle for freedom in the region.
Characters: I loved Abigail. Her inner transformation from a dependent and naïve character to a decided, independent, powerful, and ambitious character is fascinating to watch. We rarely see non-extroverts as main characters, and I loved the fact that she remained true to herself. Growing stronger throughout the book didn't mean that she had to transform and become the opposite of who she was.
Frankly, I have developed a little crush on Mr. Gabay and cannot help mooning over him in my head. His acceptance of Abigail's headstrong character and her love for astronomy, which were uncommon traits for a woman in that century, was wonderfully depicted.
Romance: The romance here is to die for. Spanning almost a year, Abigail and Mr. Gabay's romance is heartwarming and passionate.
Writing: The author Mirta Ines Trupp did a fantastic job transferring us to the nineteenth century and bringing us alongside Abigail as she experienced the revolution in Argentina. Because the book touches on astronomy, Jewish culture, and the revolution, the readers are presented with numerous accurate facts that are expertly weaved into the plot.
Recommendation: Sprinkled with a few well-placed twists, this book is a wonderful gift for readers looking for historical fiction with a classic romance.
July 23, 2021
“A sweet Regency Romance set against the backdrop of Argentina’s struggle for independence” per the author
Rating: MA: PG-17: due to the violence of war. No graphic sex; however, there was one scene that could be a trigger for some. It was an attempted assault [unsuccessful]. Prologue + 20-chapters + Epilogue. Angst Level: medium, again this was a time of war as a country fought for its independence and a lone woman struggled for hers. We also had lovers’ angst. There were skirmishes and danger that threatened characters. Source: [KU 6-30-21]. Religious Element: There was a religious thread woven throughout this story. We had references to the various religions as each group celebrated their holy days in the manner in which they worshiped. At no time did I feel that this was preachy. In fact, I was fascinated by the reverence in which our author presented her faith in conjunction with others.
SPOILER ALERT: This review may contain *** Spoilers ***
As the title states, this had references to Austen’s Persuasion. There were several Persuasion characters that we know all too well and through a series of letters were able to feel their presence. This was fun. However, Mirta Trupp did not stop there, such a sneaky author. Throughout this story, there were references to other Austen stories that made me giggle. I was impressed with how well the stories meshed together. I was constantly discovering nuggets from several stories that would spring up here and there. I had to giggle when I came across Mrs. Garrett, the housekeeper for Lord Fife.
As they say ‘War is hell’ and it was no different here. This was straight-up history in the making. The research was amazing. I had no idea of the history just south of my own borders. I was shamed in one respect but was also excited as Trupp walked me through the establishment/birthing of a new country and a place for people of all religions but especially the displaced Jews. Thankfully we were told [not shown] about the violent clashes and their results but nothing graphic. There would always be conflicts… those who advocate for independence vs those who held to the Spanish Crown and the influence of the Catholic Church.
“What sort of woman leaves her home and crosses an ocean to start anew? A brave woman. A strong woman!” quote from the book
The middle of the story slowed down a bit for me. There was so much information to digest. Like our heroine, I struggled with the language, the societal rules, customs, mode of dress, comportment, expectations, and names. Oh-My-Gosh, the names were simply beautiful. Trupp crafted the atmosphere so the reader would have an affinity for what Abigail was experiencing as she journeyed toward her future and her happy-ever-after. That was brilliant. Abigail [Avileh (Avi)] Isaacs and Mrs. Frankel, her housekeeper/companion/friend, left everything they knew and journeyed 50-days aboard ship toward their destiny and the unknown. [if you count the days, remember 1812 was a leap year]. Yeah, I’ll admit, I counted the days.
There were many surprises for our girl as she attempted to fulfill her brother’s dream. I can’t say too much as it would be a spoiler. Ah, heck. Who am I kidding? I missed the clues completely and they were as obvious as buttons on a shirt. As I read this for the second time, I wondered how I missed them in the first place.
“Non est ad astra mollis e terris via” – “There is no easy way from the earth to the stars” –Seneca
This story will leave the reader feeling many emotions. I was thrilled, mesmerized, shocked, stunned, awed, humbled, and excited. The writing was amazing. When Miss Isaacs described the galactic plane, I wanted to run outside and look up at the stars. Her love of reading, calculating, and watching the stars was fascinating. I also enjoyed the historical accounts of women professionals in her field. As she was about to cross the equator, she was preparing for a whole new set of constellations. It was intrigued.
“Though my soul may set in darkness, it will rise in perfect light;
I have loved the stars too fondly to be fearful of the night.”
–Sarah Williams, Twilight House: A Legacy of Verse
As the various holy days were described and explained, I was humbled by the dedication these two women held as they continued with their beliefs and traditions. Trupp was sensitive to the subject and displayed the various religions of the period. It was handled well and very respectful even when a character disparaged any religion that was different than their own. Our author demonstrated how such a character would act or react according to historical accounts. I didn’t care for it. It hurt my soul to read it but I know it happened. Trupp was authentic to the times. I appreciated how it was handled.
There is no way to do justice to this story in a review. The scope is too broad. I loved it and highly recommend it.
Rating: MA: PG-17: due to the violence of war. No graphic sex; however, there was one scene that could be a trigger for some. It was an attempted assault [unsuccessful]. Prologue + 20-chapters + Epilogue. Angst Level: medium, again this was a time of war as a country fought for its independence and a lone woman struggled for hers. We also had lovers’ angst. There were skirmishes and danger that threatened characters. Source: [KU 6-30-21]. Religious Element: There was a religious thread woven throughout this story. We had references to the various religions as each group celebrated their holy days in the manner in which they worshiped. At no time did I feel that this was preachy. In fact, I was fascinated by the reverence in which our author presented her faith in conjunction with others.
SPOILER ALERT: This review may contain *** Spoilers ***
As the title states, this had references to Austen’s Persuasion. There were several Persuasion characters that we know all too well and through a series of letters were able to feel their presence. This was fun. However, Mirta Trupp did not stop there, such a sneaky author. Throughout this story, there were references to other Austen stories that made me giggle. I was impressed with how well the stories meshed together. I was constantly discovering nuggets from several stories that would spring up here and there. I had to giggle when I came across Mrs. Garrett, the housekeeper for Lord Fife.
As they say ‘War is hell’ and it was no different here. This was straight-up history in the making. The research was amazing. I had no idea of the history just south of my own borders. I was shamed in one respect but was also excited as Trupp walked me through the establishment/birthing of a new country and a place for people of all religions but especially the displaced Jews. Thankfully we were told [not shown] about the violent clashes and their results but nothing graphic. There would always be conflicts… those who advocate for independence vs those who held to the Spanish Crown and the influence of the Catholic Church.
“What sort of woman leaves her home and crosses an ocean to start anew? A brave woman. A strong woman!” quote from the book
The middle of the story slowed down a bit for me. There was so much information to digest. Like our heroine, I struggled with the language, the societal rules, customs, mode of dress, comportment, expectations, and names. Oh-My-Gosh, the names were simply beautiful. Trupp crafted the atmosphere so the reader would have an affinity for what Abigail was experiencing as she journeyed toward her future and her happy-ever-after. That was brilliant. Abigail [Avileh (Avi)] Isaacs and Mrs. Frankel, her housekeeper/companion/friend, left everything they knew and journeyed 50-days aboard ship toward their destiny and the unknown. [if you count the days, remember 1812 was a leap year]. Yeah, I’ll admit, I counted the days.
There were many surprises for our girl as she attempted to fulfill her brother’s dream. I can’t say too much as it would be a spoiler. Ah, heck. Who am I kidding? I missed the clues completely and they were as obvious as buttons on a shirt. As I read this for the second time, I wondered how I missed them in the first place.
“Non est ad astra mollis e terris via” – “There is no easy way from the earth to the stars” –Seneca
This story will leave the reader feeling many emotions. I was thrilled, mesmerized, shocked, stunned, awed, humbled, and excited. The writing was amazing. When Miss Isaacs described the galactic plane, I wanted to run outside and look up at the stars. Her love of reading, calculating, and watching the stars was fascinating. I also enjoyed the historical accounts of women professionals in her field. As she was about to cross the equator, she was preparing for a whole new set of constellations. It was intrigued.
“Though my soul may set in darkness, it will rise in perfect light;
I have loved the stars too fondly to be fearful of the night.”
–Sarah Williams, Twilight House: A Legacy of Verse
As the various holy days were described and explained, I was humbled by the dedication these two women held as they continued with their beliefs and traditions. Trupp was sensitive to the subject and displayed the various religions of the period. It was handled well and very respectful even when a character disparaged any religion that was different than their own. Our author demonstrated how such a character would act or react according to historical accounts. I didn’t care for it. It hurt my soul to read it but I know it happened. Trupp was authentic to the times. I appreciated how it was handled.
There is no way to do justice to this story in a review. The scope is too broad. I loved it and highly recommend it.
January 15, 2023
I learned a great deal about Argentinian and Jewish history from this unique, well-researched novel, and I especially appreciated Avileh or Abigail’s strength of character. Other characters (often men, even the men who love her most) sometimes underestimated her, but she doesn’t hesitate to stand up for herself, her beliefs, and her intelligence — yet she does so in a way that fits within the time period, too. All in all, this was a richly detailed reminder that there was (and is) no single way of being in the world.
March 2, 2022
Okay y’all, I know this is not my typical book, but I do not for one second regret reading this book. It is a historical fiction and is supposedly the prequel to Jane Austen’s Persuasion. However, you don’t have to be an Austen fan to enjoy this book. This book was incredibly well researched and depicts not only the struggles of women at the time, but also the prejudices against religion. I will admit that I had my reservations about the portrayal of the Jews and their religion and heritage in book form, but Ms. Tripp put all those reservations to rest. This book speaks to the traditions and customs of the Jews without pushing it or destroying its integrity. The heroine sets off on an adventure to Buenos Aires at the behest of her brother. The journey is told with historical accuracy and we get to see the start of freedom for that region of the world and what that looks like for them. The romance is a back story but if you are a fan of history, this book will be for you. A caveat is the language is “old-timey” as it is period accurate so be aware while reading you might need a dictionary.
June 18, 2022
A beautifully written regency romance novel that had me hooked from beginning to end.
Anyone who knows me know full well that I am a huge fan of historical fiction and Trupp’s novel did not disappoint. From the language (appropriately regency) to the characters (delightfully Austen-esque) to the plot (grand adventure + romance + the stars) it’s safe to say it ticked all of my boxes.
With a focus on the Jewish community and culture, as well as South America’s fight for independence from Spain, I was immersed in a beautiful balance of both facts and fiction written in a way that was easily understandable.
Trupp has truly done justice to Austen with this novel, in both the witty banter and the delightful miscommunication between Abigail and Mr Gabay. All the characters in Celestial Persuasion felt real with hints of Austen’s influence intertwined seamlessly. I particularly enjoyed experiencing Abigail grow as a character, Mr Gabay’s acceptance of her as the headstrong, intelligent and independent woman that she is, and her burgeoning friendship with Captain Wentworth.
It was a beautiful - and educational - read that I’m confident I will pick up and read again. Would highly recommend for those who adore a classic romance and regency fiction.
Anyone who knows me know full well that I am a huge fan of historical fiction and Trupp’s novel did not disappoint. From the language (appropriately regency) to the characters (delightfully Austen-esque) to the plot (grand adventure + romance + the stars) it’s safe to say it ticked all of my boxes.
With a focus on the Jewish community and culture, as well as South America’s fight for independence from Spain, I was immersed in a beautiful balance of both facts and fiction written in a way that was easily understandable.
Trupp has truly done justice to Austen with this novel, in both the witty banter and the delightful miscommunication between Abigail and Mr Gabay. All the characters in Celestial Persuasion felt real with hints of Austen’s influence intertwined seamlessly. I particularly enjoyed experiencing Abigail grow as a character, Mr Gabay’s acceptance of her as the headstrong, intelligent and independent woman that she is, and her burgeoning friendship with Captain Wentworth.
It was a beautiful - and educational - read that I’m confident I will pick up and read again. Would highly recommend for those who adore a classic romance and regency fiction.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 5, 2022
Truly original
A really imaginative plot that includes some of Persuasion,s characters and goes on to create an incredible group of people and circumstances that keeps you reading this tale. Thoroughly entertaining and recommended!
A really imaginative plot that includes some of Persuasion,s characters and goes on to create an incredible group of people and circumstances that keeps you reading this tale. Thoroughly entertaining and recommended!
August 3, 2022
A 5-Star review is not enough for this masterpiece penned by the talented Mirta Ines Trupp!
I was impressed with both the captivating storyline and character development in this book. The perfect escape to Regency England and Argentina!
I was impressed with both the captivating storyline and character development in this book. The perfect escape to Regency England and Argentina!
September 14, 2023
When travesty hits a lovely, lonely Jewish woman astronomer, she makes the decision to leave all she knows and follow the path across the sea to fulfill her beloved brother’s final wish. A sweeping journey of the heart is also cleverly made into a prequel to Jane Austen’s Persuasion by the talented writing of Mirta Ines Trupp.
Opening with a heartbreaking prequel showing how Royal Navy physician Joseph Isaacs came under the lash of a sadistic evil captain and able to give his final words to his friend gallant Captain Wentworth, the story switches to the perspective of Joseph’s younger sister, Abigail Isaacs.
Abigail has spent her life in Exeter as the bright, brilliant daughter of a country doctor. Jewish and educated beyond what could be expected for women, she is an astronomer and mathematician with few rivals. After the death of her father and now her beloved brother, Joseph, she is left with no one and very little to live on. Then Lord Fife, her brother’s friend invites her to London to hear his bizarre proposal that Joseph and her father set in motion before their deaths. If she will step out on faith, they have arranged for her to have a home and a little farm in the contested former Spanish colony in South America that will become Argentina. Her brother was part of a group of men who will see the colony free of the Spanish rule and a haven for all including Jews and a place where educated women can push past the barriers set against them. She might also find love if she is brave enough to allow it past the cold wall of logic she had encased herself in.
I love the Regency era and particularly when the setting is on the high seas for an Age of Sail story. What a wonderful background to give the heroine and time spend with the astronomy element. Abigail’s journey and the early days of newly forming Argentina, her tempestuous relationship with a handsome Spanish Jewish military officer, and her coming into her own made for a heartwarming and engaging story. On the side was her continuing correspondence with Captain Wentworth which Austen lovers like myself know will lead to a fabulous second chance love story in Persuasion. For those who love seeing character growth and a slow burn sweet romance against a colorful historical setting, Celestial Persuasion is an excellent choice for the reading stack.
My full review will post at Books of My Heart on 9.3.23
Opening with a heartbreaking prequel showing how Royal Navy physician Joseph Isaacs came under the lash of a sadistic evil captain and able to give his final words to his friend gallant Captain Wentworth, the story switches to the perspective of Joseph’s younger sister, Abigail Isaacs.
Abigail has spent her life in Exeter as the bright, brilliant daughter of a country doctor. Jewish and educated beyond what could be expected for women, she is an astronomer and mathematician with few rivals. After the death of her father and now her beloved brother, Joseph, she is left with no one and very little to live on. Then Lord Fife, her brother’s friend invites her to London to hear his bizarre proposal that Joseph and her father set in motion before their deaths. If she will step out on faith, they have arranged for her to have a home and a little farm in the contested former Spanish colony in South America that will become Argentina. Her brother was part of a group of men who will see the colony free of the Spanish rule and a haven for all including Jews and a place where educated women can push past the barriers set against them. She might also find love if she is brave enough to allow it past the cold wall of logic she had encased herself in.
I love the Regency era and particularly when the setting is on the high seas for an Age of Sail story. What a wonderful background to give the heroine and time spend with the astronomy element. Abigail’s journey and the early days of newly forming Argentina, her tempestuous relationship with a handsome Spanish Jewish military officer, and her coming into her own made for a heartwarming and engaging story. On the side was her continuing correspondence with Captain Wentworth which Austen lovers like myself know will lead to a fabulous second chance love story in Persuasion. For those who love seeing character growth and a slow burn sweet romance against a colorful historical setting, Celestial Persuasion is an excellent choice for the reading stack.
My full review will post at Books of My Heart on 9.3.23
November 9, 2021
Jane Austen fan fiction. The main character, Abigail Isaacs, is a Jewish woman who is friends with Mrs Dashwood (from Sense & Sensibility), and who meets Captain Wentworth (from Persuasion) due to her brother's service in the Royal Navy. As with several of Austen's characters, Miss Isaac's meets with financial challenges after her father dies. Unlike Austen's characters, she moves to Argentina!
I liked the premise of the story, but I never really felt that the author had a voice of her own. There were substantial parts of the book that were educational, about Argentine history and about Jewish customs, but the characters and the romantic relationship seemed to be an attempt to mimic Jane Austen instead of developing on their own.
I liked the premise of the story, but I never really felt that the author had a voice of her own. There were substantial parts of the book that were educational, about Argentine history and about Jewish customs, but the characters and the romantic relationship seemed to be an attempt to mimic Jane Austen instead of developing on their own.
March 2, 2022
Celestial Persuasion by Mirta Ines Trupp was a beautiful story. I really enjoyed everything about it, and I just love history, so I had a good time reading it. This book was definitely an interesting experience because I have never read a book set up this way, but the writing was good. I've never read Persuasion by Jane Austen so I cannot make a good comparison, but Celestial Persuasion could be considered a prequel to Persuasion. This book talks about important historic topics, and I loved how the author conveyed the message. Great job, Mirta!
Read Celestial Persuasion by Mirta Ines Trupp to go back in time and get the experience of your life!
"Most characters and events in this publication are fiction. Creative license has been used surrounding true historical events and/or personages of the era. This work contains characters created by Miss Jane Austen. These works are in the public domain. Although the author writes from a Jewish perspective, not every belief and doctrine expressed in this book may agree with the beliefs and doctrines of any of the three major Jewish branches."- Author's Note
Read Celestial Persuasion by Mirta Ines Trupp to go back in time and get the experience of your life!
"Most characters and events in this publication are fiction. Creative license has been used surrounding true historical events and/or personages of the era. This work contains characters created by Miss Jane Austen. These works are in the public domain. Although the author writes from a Jewish perspective, not every belief and doctrine expressed in this book may agree with the beliefs and doctrines of any of the three major Jewish branches."- Author's Note
July 31, 2021
If there is a valid criticism of Jane Austen it is that her books lack diversity. Many JAFF writers have attempted to redress that shortcoming, often with nearly unreadable results. Anyone who would like to write an Austenation with more diverse voices ought to read this book (and the author's previous Austenation) to see how it should be done. This isn't just good JAFF, it's darned good historical fiction. Well written, beautifully researched, and absolutely fascinating. The Austen cameos, as they appeared, were always both true to their Austen origins, and organic to the story. I'm rather partial to Captain Wentworth so I tend to be particular about how he appears in JAFF -- he was wonderful in this novel. But enough from me -- everybody just run and get this book and read it! You won't be sorry.
June 30, 2021
Once again, Mirta Ines Trupp writes a lovely prequel to Jane Austen’s work. This time it's Persuasion. But as usual, Trupp includes a twist, in fact, many of them. The female protagonist is Jewish and she’s heading to Buenos Aires in the midst of a revolution. This allows Trupp to inform her readers about the history and the heroes of Argentina, the 19th century Jewish Argentinian community, and the contributions of the women at that time. Devotees of Austen’s work, who never wanted her stories to end, will enjoy Trupp’s writing, and those who have adored Persuasion, will not be disappointed in what could possibly come after. I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
October 8, 2023
I really enjoy Mirta Ines Trupp's writing - the storyline flows so easily throughout the book, it is hard to put down. I highly recommend!!
July 2, 2022
This book! Historical fiction hasn’t ever really been my favorite genre but this book did it so well. I was hooked from beginning and I couldn’t put it down!! Not only is it a beautiful story, but it’s also factual and educational. I remember learning about South America’s fight for independence from Spain and Río de la Plata in my college Spanish class. And the romance between Abigail and Mr. Gabay is so perfectly Austen-esque ❤️
If you’re a fan of Jane Austen, this is a book you need to read! I bet she would’ve loved it!!
*I received a free copy for an honest review*
If you’re a fan of Jane Austen, this is a book you need to read! I bet she would’ve loved it!!
*I received a free copy for an honest review*
July 3, 2022
Celestial Persuasion is quite the read that everyone needs to be aware of!
I fell in love with the plot, it drew me in right away and the characters took me for an adventure. Absolutely loved watching their development along the way.
If there’s one thing I had to focus on it would be the writing. I love the way the author developed their characters. Right from the beginning I knew I was in for a great read and I loved it.
I fell in love with the plot, it drew me in right away and the characters took me for an adventure. Absolutely loved watching their development along the way.
If there’s one thing I had to focus on it would be the writing. I love the way the author developed their characters. Right from the beginning I knew I was in for a great read and I loved it.
July 5, 2021
This author has done it again! Trupp has successfully married her two passions into an extremely satisfying novel. The storyline is unique, yet it will delight Janeites with its connections to "Persuasion" and nods to other of Austen’s work. And can we talk about those letters? They were brilliant! In fact, THE LETTER written in the narrative by Lieutenant Gabay rivals Captain Wentworth’s famous words, and combines the worlds of Regency Romance with Judaic fiction in a most clever and fulfilling manner.
Trupp met all my benchmarks with this story. This a sweet, inspirational romance with a strong, outspoken heroine. The author takes us out of England and introduces us to a new setting—one that experiences its own Regency era— filled with captivating characters, handsome officers and intriguing scenarios. The author cleverly weaves Captain Wentworth into the storyline, but this is much more than a prequel to Austen’s "Persuasion." Trupp doesn’t imitate or copy, as we see so often times in fan fiction. Her style is unique, and this story is certainly one that most readers have never come across. The Jewish element is delightful, but not overdone. The historical details are fascinating. And the ending…or rather, was it the beginning? I am certain that Jane Austen would approve.
Trupp met all my benchmarks with this story. This a sweet, inspirational romance with a strong, outspoken heroine. The author takes us out of England and introduces us to a new setting—one that experiences its own Regency era— filled with captivating characters, handsome officers and intriguing scenarios. The author cleverly weaves Captain Wentworth into the storyline, but this is much more than a prequel to Austen’s "Persuasion." Trupp doesn’t imitate or copy, as we see so often times in fan fiction. Her style is unique, and this story is certainly one that most readers have never come across. The Jewish element is delightful, but not overdone. The historical details are fascinating. And the ending…or rather, was it the beginning? I am certain that Jane Austen would approve.
November 6, 2021
“Though we may be persuaded by their guidance, we may freely choose to rise above their prescribed limitations. Follow the dictates of the stars, Captain, but blaze your own trail.”
This delightfully written story is a prequel to Jane Austen’s Persuasion and done in such a lovely way that you sometimes wonder if Miss Austen, herself, penned the words. Ms Trupp’s Abigail Isaacs is a brave young woman dedicated to studying the stars, forever looking up to the heavens and steering away from looking inside her own heart, especially after she is left alone in the world with only the stars to guide her.
After receiving a tragic letter from Captain Wentworth (of Austen’s Persuasion), Abigail is thrust into a whirlwind of fulfilling her brother’s dreams in the far away Viceroyalty of Rio de la Plata in Buenos Aires. This is a wonderful departure from the English scenery of Miss Austen’s books and gives the reader another view of Regency life on the seas and across the world, and is done splendidly!
Along the voyage to this new country, Abigail encounters her own Mr Darcy in the personage of Mr Raphael Gabay, a Lieutenant who has offered his services to the Spanish American cause AND who has lent his arm to care for the passage of Abigail and her companion, Mrs Frankel. Mr Gabay embodies a true Austenesque man and holds his own, shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Mr Darcy and Mr Knightley of Pride and Prejudice and Emma fame. Abigail finds herself drawn to him and exasperated by him at the same instance... and Raphael wonders whether Abigail will ever look past her star-gazing and her own prideful assumptions about him to see his true heart.
Like a eloquent constellation, this novel is so perfectly planned out and executed – a vast sparkling tribute to Miss Austen’s Regency world, even including some of her characters such as Captain Wentworth, aforementioned, Mrs Dashwood, and Mrs Jennings from Sense and Sensibility. I adored how Mrs Jennings was still ‘winkling a way’ into finding out information about Abigail’s situation.
“Shakespeare himself could not have conceived of a tale so replete with discord and misunderstandings.”
Another clever insinuation into the storyline is Ms Trupp’s presentation of the Jewish experience in Regency England and in Rio de la Plata. So much history about the displaced Jewish people during that time, as well as insightful information about how holidays are performed, as well as the strict observance of the moon instead of the sun in the religious calendar. And not only that, but she infused Abigail’s love for astronomy into this beautifully written story, as well as the historical facts of the birth of this new nation which becomes Argentina. The struggle, the fight for independence, is masterfully woven into Abigail’s story without feeling overtly heavy. We are provided with enough information to clearly see the history which is captivating and illuminating much like the first vision Abigail sees of the Milky Way as the ship crosses the equator.
“What sort of woman leaves her home and crosses an ocean to start anew? A brave woman. A strong woman!”
With Austen’s Regency books we are used to being presented with a flurry of stories, nowadays, still stuck in England or in the European landscape, so this take on a Regency novel was quite refreshing and, without a doubt, would receive a nod of approval from Jane Austen. As with most of Miss Austen’s main female characters, Abigail represents a woman of her time stuck between a desire for independence and a world where woman cannot make her own fortune and must marry a man of means to ensure her future; and yet, she is desperate to find her own way. The adventure across the ocean to Rio de la Plata is a daring (and sometimes dangerous) breakaway which reminds me of Marianne’s racing across the hills to find blue sky, her abandonment of sensibility which brings her tumbling into reality. I was truly amazed how Ms Trupp seemed to take elements of all of Miss Austen’s female characters and mold them into the character of Abigail Isaacs.
“That a woman – of age, well-read, and well-educated – could not be expected to comprehend the stirrings of the heart when men grew passionate for a cause, or grew restless for change, was a grave affront indeed. That her beloved father, who carefully nurtured her every curiosity, and her brother, who lovingly shared every lesson learned, would believe her to be insensible or incapable of aspiring to better the world tore at her heart. She strove to maintain some sort of equanimity but the nature of the events was far too implausible to allow.”
It is obvious that the author has studied Miss Austen’s style of writing very well, for the book flows with exceptional quality and an easiness which reflects well the verbiage, customs, and traditions of the Regency world. Even at some points when the storyline slows a bit, this too is a reflection of Miss Austen’s books which, to my mind, have been referred to by many as too many words to read, too superfluous, which I think is necessary in a genuine Austen-like spin-off. There is no doubt that readers who are die-hard Austen fans will find a new author to love when reading Celestial Persuasion for in every way this book enlightens, satisfies, and gives us a new way of looking at the Regency world while clarifying her own voice apart from Jane Austen.
Bravo, Ms Trupp, bravo! Austen-esque fans will certainly look forward to this book and to ones to follow.
Celestial Persuasion is awarded five stars and the “Highly Recommended” award by The Historical Fiction Company.
This delightfully written story is a prequel to Jane Austen’s Persuasion and done in such a lovely way that you sometimes wonder if Miss Austen, herself, penned the words. Ms Trupp’s Abigail Isaacs is a brave young woman dedicated to studying the stars, forever looking up to the heavens and steering away from looking inside her own heart, especially after she is left alone in the world with only the stars to guide her.
After receiving a tragic letter from Captain Wentworth (of Austen’s Persuasion), Abigail is thrust into a whirlwind of fulfilling her brother’s dreams in the far away Viceroyalty of Rio de la Plata in Buenos Aires. This is a wonderful departure from the English scenery of Miss Austen’s books and gives the reader another view of Regency life on the seas and across the world, and is done splendidly!
Along the voyage to this new country, Abigail encounters her own Mr Darcy in the personage of Mr Raphael Gabay, a Lieutenant who has offered his services to the Spanish American cause AND who has lent his arm to care for the passage of Abigail and her companion, Mrs Frankel. Mr Gabay embodies a true Austenesque man and holds his own, shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Mr Darcy and Mr Knightley of Pride and Prejudice and Emma fame. Abigail finds herself drawn to him and exasperated by him at the same instance... and Raphael wonders whether Abigail will ever look past her star-gazing and her own prideful assumptions about him to see his true heart.
Like a eloquent constellation, this novel is so perfectly planned out and executed – a vast sparkling tribute to Miss Austen’s Regency world, even including some of her characters such as Captain Wentworth, aforementioned, Mrs Dashwood, and Mrs Jennings from Sense and Sensibility. I adored how Mrs Jennings was still ‘winkling a way’ into finding out information about Abigail’s situation.
“Shakespeare himself could not have conceived of a tale so replete with discord and misunderstandings.”
Another clever insinuation into the storyline is Ms Trupp’s presentation of the Jewish experience in Regency England and in Rio de la Plata. So much history about the displaced Jewish people during that time, as well as insightful information about how holidays are performed, as well as the strict observance of the moon instead of the sun in the religious calendar. And not only that, but she infused Abigail’s love for astronomy into this beautifully written story, as well as the historical facts of the birth of this new nation which becomes Argentina. The struggle, the fight for independence, is masterfully woven into Abigail’s story without feeling overtly heavy. We are provided with enough information to clearly see the history which is captivating and illuminating much like the first vision Abigail sees of the Milky Way as the ship crosses the equator.
“What sort of woman leaves her home and crosses an ocean to start anew? A brave woman. A strong woman!”
With Austen’s Regency books we are used to being presented with a flurry of stories, nowadays, still stuck in England or in the European landscape, so this take on a Regency novel was quite refreshing and, without a doubt, would receive a nod of approval from Jane Austen. As with most of Miss Austen’s main female characters, Abigail represents a woman of her time stuck between a desire for independence and a world where woman cannot make her own fortune and must marry a man of means to ensure her future; and yet, she is desperate to find her own way. The adventure across the ocean to Rio de la Plata is a daring (and sometimes dangerous) breakaway which reminds me of Marianne’s racing across the hills to find blue sky, her abandonment of sensibility which brings her tumbling into reality. I was truly amazed how Ms Trupp seemed to take elements of all of Miss Austen’s female characters and mold them into the character of Abigail Isaacs.
“That a woman – of age, well-read, and well-educated – could not be expected to comprehend the stirrings of the heart when men grew passionate for a cause, or grew restless for change, was a grave affront indeed. That her beloved father, who carefully nurtured her every curiosity, and her brother, who lovingly shared every lesson learned, would believe her to be insensible or incapable of aspiring to better the world tore at her heart. She strove to maintain some sort of equanimity but the nature of the events was far too implausible to allow.”
It is obvious that the author has studied Miss Austen’s style of writing very well, for the book flows with exceptional quality and an easiness which reflects well the verbiage, customs, and traditions of the Regency world. Even at some points when the storyline slows a bit, this too is a reflection of Miss Austen’s books which, to my mind, have been referred to by many as too many words to read, too superfluous, which I think is necessary in a genuine Austen-like spin-off. There is no doubt that readers who are die-hard Austen fans will find a new author to love when reading Celestial Persuasion for in every way this book enlightens, satisfies, and gives us a new way of looking at the Regency world while clarifying her own voice apart from Jane Austen.
Bravo, Ms Trupp, bravo! Austen-esque fans will certainly look forward to this book and to ones to follow.
Celestial Persuasion is awarded five stars and the “Highly Recommended” award by The Historical Fiction Company.
July 5, 2022
"Offering my heart, which you so easily dismiss. Offering my soul, which you so callously deem to be ill suited to pair with yours. Might I suggest you set down your astronomer’s paraphernalia to examine what is before you, here on earth, and not in the night’s sky? You have excused me of shielding my truths with incessant jesting, but it is you, madam, who hides behind instruments and tomes. It is you, with your improper pride, who refuses to acknowledge the realities of life. No, I shall not attempt to persuade you; but rather, allow me to wish you well. Only do not fall off the face of the earth, once you realize all is not what you believe it to be.”
I was oh so presently surprised when I was given this book in exchange for an honest review. As someone who was absolutely obsessed with all things Jane Austen as a teenager (yes I watched the 8hr long pride and prejudice multiple times!) this book made me smile in its many references to my favorite Jane Austen novel, Persuasion. The letters back in forth between Captain Wentworth and The main character Abigail are truly enjoyable, with encouragement for him to fix things with Anne. This was a fun prequel idea and I loved how the author wrapped in so much knowledge of the Jewish religion and also the passion the main character has for the stars was also something different and fun to read about. I do feel like there was so much information thrown at you really fast, but that's what gave you the feel of a "classic" Austen type novel, however it was way easier to understand than the old fashioned language mumbo jumbo! Overall this was a great book I couldn't put down!
I give Celestial Persuasion by Mirta Ines Trupp ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I was oh so presently surprised when I was given this book in exchange for an honest review. As someone who was absolutely obsessed with all things Jane Austen as a teenager (yes I watched the 8hr long pride and prejudice multiple times!) this book made me smile in its many references to my favorite Jane Austen novel, Persuasion. The letters back in forth between Captain Wentworth and The main character Abigail are truly enjoyable, with encouragement for him to fix things with Anne. This was a fun prequel idea and I loved how the author wrapped in so much knowledge of the Jewish religion and also the passion the main character has for the stars was also something different and fun to read about. I do feel like there was so much information thrown at you really fast, but that's what gave you the feel of a "classic" Austen type novel, however it was way easier to understand than the old fashioned language mumbo jumbo! Overall this was a great book I couldn't put down!
I give Celestial Persuasion by Mirta Ines Trupp ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
June 15, 2022
Am I Janeite? Yes.
Did I have high expectations going into this read? You betcha.
Friends, let me tell ya, this book was an absolute delight from start to finish, exceeding the (already quite high) bar I’d mentally set for it. In fact, I’d even go so far as to say that this is a rendition even Ms. Austen herself would approve of.
This book is more of a “prequel” to Persuasion, rather than a retelling. It’s full of Austen nuggets, which I really appreciated.
The novel is set in colonial Argentina- a region refreshing to “travel to” in terms of the Regency era. Major themes include the limited struggles of women during that time period, as well as religious persecution.
Trupp’s attention to detail was superb; the history intricately woven into her narrative. The main character, Abigail, is one this reader will remember for a long time.
My favorite excerpt? Others have noted it, too, because — yes — it’s THAT good.
“Though we may be persuaded by their guidance, we may freely choose to rise above their prescribed limitations. Follow the dictates of the stars, Captain, but blaze your own trail.”
I was provided with a copy of the eBook from the author. These opinions are my own and I am voluntarily leaving my review.
Did I have high expectations going into this read? You betcha.
Friends, let me tell ya, this book was an absolute delight from start to finish, exceeding the (already quite high) bar I’d mentally set for it. In fact, I’d even go so far as to say that this is a rendition even Ms. Austen herself would approve of.
This book is more of a “prequel” to Persuasion, rather than a retelling. It’s full of Austen nuggets, which I really appreciated.
The novel is set in colonial Argentina- a region refreshing to “travel to” in terms of the Regency era. Major themes include the limited struggles of women during that time period, as well as religious persecution.
Trupp’s attention to detail was superb; the history intricately woven into her narrative. The main character, Abigail, is one this reader will remember for a long time.
My favorite excerpt? Others have noted it, too, because — yes — it’s THAT good.
“Though we may be persuaded by their guidance, we may freely choose to rise above their prescribed limitations. Follow the dictates of the stars, Captain, but blaze your own trail.”
I was provided with a copy of the eBook from the author. These opinions are my own and I am voluntarily leaving my review.
July 3, 2022
4.5 ⭐️
Oh my where do I begin!
Regency Era writing at its finest. Coming off of many "modern" fantasy novels for lack of a better term, Trupp's way with words is so refreshing. Reminding me of my love for women's historical fiction and romance.
This prequel to Jane Austen's Persuasion, takes you instantly to it's place and time. The writing romantic and flowing beautifully to immerse you in the story. I was completely engrossed from start to finish.
Abigail loses her father and soon after her brother. After receiving notice from Captain Wentworth, she is provided information that surprises her and makes her uncertain of her future. She begins her journey to South America in honor of her brother's final wishes and to see his dreams fulfilled. Accompanied by her new aquantaince Mr. Gabay, Abigail finds her hardened heart, softening.
The history in this story was so interesting and not something I'd ever read about before. We learn of the Viceroyalty of Rio de la Plata's fight for freedom from Spanish rule and a bit of Jewish history touching on some of the hardships Jews have endured in society.
The romance is as Jane Austen-esque as you would have hoped. I giggled, swooned, and loved the witty conversations between Abigail and Mr. Gabay. I loved everything about this book and highly recommend to all Jane Austen fans and those who love historical fiction.
Oh my where do I begin!
Regency Era writing at its finest. Coming off of many "modern" fantasy novels for lack of a better term, Trupp's way with words is so refreshing. Reminding me of my love for women's historical fiction and romance.
This prequel to Jane Austen's Persuasion, takes you instantly to it's place and time. The writing romantic and flowing beautifully to immerse you in the story. I was completely engrossed from start to finish.
Abigail loses her father and soon after her brother. After receiving notice from Captain Wentworth, she is provided information that surprises her and makes her uncertain of her future. She begins her journey to South America in honor of her brother's final wishes and to see his dreams fulfilled. Accompanied by her new aquantaince Mr. Gabay, Abigail finds her hardened heart, softening.
The history in this story was so interesting and not something I'd ever read about before. We learn of the Viceroyalty of Rio de la Plata's fight for freedom from Spanish rule and a bit of Jewish history touching on some of the hardships Jews have endured in society.
The romance is as Jane Austen-esque as you would have hoped. I giggled, swooned, and loved the witty conversations between Abigail and Mr. Gabay. I loved everything about this book and highly recommend to all Jane Austen fans and those who love historical fiction.
August 29, 2021
Celestial Persuasion completely transported me to a different age and time with the compelling story of Miss Abigail Isaacs. Meticulously researched and beautifully written, this prequel to Jane Austen's Persuasion hooked me from the get-go. The authentic characters, the Jewish elements, the real history, and of course the romance combine to make this novel a wonderful reading experience.
May 18, 2022
Written in a Jane Austen style, we follow the characters to South America and learn of the plight of some of the Jewish people during that time. I enjoyed it. Different than I thought it would be, but well done. Abigail was a great character with flaws that seemed believable. The romance was very Austen like and a very interesting twist to introducing Captain Wentworth.
June 13, 2022
A beautifully written novel combining history and Jane Austen mannerisms! I will admit that I never understood nor really got into Austen's novels but I can honestly say I get it now! With "Celestial Persuasion" serving as a prequel to Austen's own Persuasion I can now go into Austen's writing with a new found excitement!
Abigail Isaacs served as a wonderful main character and it was a joy to follow her adventure from England to Buenos Aries. To watch her come into her own independence and find love along the way was so beautiful to read! Oh and Mr. Gabay oh I loved him! His persistent attitude and his willingness to let Abigail still tend to her work in Astronomy was the cherry on top!
Abigail Isaacs served as a wonderful main character and it was a joy to follow her adventure from England to Buenos Aries. To watch her come into her own independence and find love along the way was so beautiful to read! Oh and Mr. Gabay oh I loved him! His persistent attitude and his willingness to let Abigail still tend to her work in Astronomy was the cherry on top!
May 26, 2022
This book is beautiful! The writing, the history, the languages, the diversity in the characters. It is Regency Era fiction with more depth (Don’t come for me please. I love Jane Austen.) I learned so much about Jewish history and astronomy and about immigration to Argentina at the time. I felt like I was in South America star gazing with Abigail. I love when a book is interesting, captivating, heartwarming AND teaches me more about the world and other people I didn’t know before. This book is exceptionally well researched and reminds me of everything I love about historical fiction. I loved the Author’s Note as well. I highly recommend this one. You will enjoy it, learn while reading it and be glad you did.
Mirta Ines Trupp, you have won my heart with this one!
Synopsis from the book: Abigail Isaacs fears ever again falling under the power of love and dedicates her life to studying the heavens. However, upon her father’s demise she finds herself in reduced circumstances and must write to her brother, who has long been away at sea. When instead Captain Wentworth of the HMS Laconia sends a tragic reply, Abigail is asked to set aside her own ambitions and fulfill her brother’s dreams in the Viceroyalty of Río de la Plata.
In his relentless pursuit for justice, Lieutenant Raphael Gabay lends his sword to the Spanish American cause. But as he prepares to set sail with the others, he is entrusted with the care of a young woman. She is quite unlike anyone he has ever known, and Raphael begins to wonder whether the brilliant astronomer will see beyond his frivolous façade and recognize his true nature.
Their destinies have been plotted beyond the celestial veil; their charts foretell of adventure. Can these two troubled souls be persuaded to heed the stars and find love—and their purpose—in this fledgling nation?
Mirta Ines Trupp, you have won my heart with this one!
Synopsis from the book: Abigail Isaacs fears ever again falling under the power of love and dedicates her life to studying the heavens. However, upon her father’s demise she finds herself in reduced circumstances and must write to her brother, who has long been away at sea. When instead Captain Wentworth of the HMS Laconia sends a tragic reply, Abigail is asked to set aside her own ambitions and fulfill her brother’s dreams in the Viceroyalty of Río de la Plata.
In his relentless pursuit for justice, Lieutenant Raphael Gabay lends his sword to the Spanish American cause. But as he prepares to set sail with the others, he is entrusted with the care of a young woman. She is quite unlike anyone he has ever known, and Raphael begins to wonder whether the brilliant astronomer will see beyond his frivolous façade and recognize his true nature.
Their destinies have been plotted beyond the celestial veil; their charts foretell of adventure. Can these two troubled souls be persuaded to heed the stars and find love—and their purpose—in this fledgling nation?
July 13, 2021
Give me nights perfectly quiet... and I looking up at the stars... ~ Walt Whitman
“Celestial Persuasion” is an unusual book for me — a JAFF that is not based on Pride & Prejudice.
Instead, this story intersects with characters from “Persuasion”. Captain Wentworth is a good friend to our heroine’s brother whose path crosses with one of the Musgrove sons.
Abigail Isaacs, a young Jewish woman, is persuaded to emigrate from England to Argentina. She arrives at a critical point in the history of Argentina.
I am mad with the sight of stars, and frenzied with the beauty of the silver, wanton moon. ~ Muriel Strode
Abigail, a scientist, is interested in the study of stars. She is based on an actual historical character.
I loved this heroine and her story. I also learned some history of Argentina and the Jewish people who came to live there.
Highest recommendations!
To be glad of life, because it gives you the chance to love and to work and to play and to look up at the stars... and to spend as much time as you can, with body and with spirit, in God's out-of-doors — these are little guide-posts on the foot-path to peace. ~ Henry Van Dyke
“Celestial Persuasion” is an unusual book for me — a JAFF that is not based on Pride & Prejudice.
Instead, this story intersects with characters from “Persuasion”. Captain Wentworth is a good friend to our heroine’s brother whose path crosses with one of the Musgrove sons.
Abigail Isaacs, a young Jewish woman, is persuaded to emigrate from England to Argentina. She arrives at a critical point in the history of Argentina.
I am mad with the sight of stars, and frenzied with the beauty of the silver, wanton moon. ~ Muriel Strode
Abigail, a scientist, is interested in the study of stars. She is based on an actual historical character.
I loved this heroine and her story. I also learned some history of Argentina and the Jewish people who came to live there.
Highest recommendations!
To be glad of life, because it gives you the chance to love and to work and to play and to look up at the stars... and to spend as much time as you can, with body and with spirit, in God's out-of-doors — these are little guide-posts on the foot-path to peace. ~ Henry Van Dyke
August 21, 2021
Editorial Review:
...At its heart, "Celestial Persuasion" is a deftly developed romance between two equally matched people caught up in a whirlwind of longing, loss, and the possibility of enduring love.
Mirta Ines Trupp has brought the past to life in her story-telling, her wide knowledge of history, and her genuine wish to connect with an earlier, similarly gifted woman and wordsmith.~ Feathered Quill Book Awards and Reviews
...At its heart, "Celestial Persuasion" is a deftly developed romance between two equally matched people caught up in a whirlwind of longing, loss, and the possibility of enduring love.
Mirta Ines Trupp has brought the past to life in her story-telling, her wide knowledge of history, and her genuine wish to connect with an earlier, similarly gifted woman and wordsmith.~ Feathered Quill Book Awards and Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews